After I Got My MBA, the 3 Things I Changed First in My Horse Business — Highbrow Ranch article cover

After I Got My MBA, Here Are the 3 Things I Changed First in My Horse Business

Horse business 8 min read

After I Got My MBA, Here Are the 3 Things I Changed First in My Horse Business

Kate Toomey Evans — 6× National Champion and World Champion equestrian. 10,000 hours teaching beginner riders.

A bay horse walking across a green pasture

Business school taught me nothing about horses. Here are the three things I changed first — including cutting most of my client list on purpose.

What it taught me was how to look at my own barn. Not “do I like it?” But: what is this really built on? Where is it faking it?

I was good at the horse part. The business part I did by feel, like most of us do. I worked harder every year. And I kept wondering why that never turned into money.

Here are the three things I changed first.

1

I got my numbers

That's it. That's the first one.

I sat down and found out what I was really spending and what was really coming in. Line by line.

Let me tell you how that went.

I'm good at math. I want to be clear about that. This is not a story about a woman who can't handle numbers.

It still took me tens of hours.

The math was never the hard part. The hard part was that my numbers lived in about nine different places.

Before
Feed receipts (glove box) Vet bills (email) Board checks (notebook) Fuel + hay (bank app) Lesson income (in my head)

Everywhere. All true. Useless.

After
One page
$Cost per horse per day
$Cost per lesson hour
$What you charge now
$What you should charge
$What you keep

Same numbers. Completely different feeling.

Nine places, or one. That was the whole difference.

Feed receipts in the glove box. Vet bills in my email. Board checks in a notebook. Fuel and hay in the bank app. Lesson income mostly in my head.

Every one of those was true. Together they were useless. I could never see them all at once.

So I'd add things up. Then I'd find a bill I forgot. Then I'd start over.

Here's what I finally figured out. I didn't need to be better at math.

I needed a system.

One place. Stays organized. Still makes sense in February.

So I built one. That's where my pricing calculator came from. It's the thing I made for myself so I'd never do it the hard way again.

You don't have to spend the hours I spent.

The Horse Business Pricing Calculator is the system I built for myself. The formulas are already in it. Put your costs in. It tells you what one horse and one lesson hour really cost you.

See the Pricing Calculator →

Why does this matter so much?

Because you can't cut your way to profit if you don't know what to cut. And growing a service that loses money just gets you to the bottom faster.

2

I changed the program, and lost most of my clients on purpose

Once I could see my numbers, the problem was obvious.

I had fifty clients. Each one bought very little. Fifty families to keep up with. Fifty bills to chase.

And chase is the right word. I was not getting paid by all of them.

So I changed two rules.

Rule one

Everybody rides twice a week.

Once a week isn't enough to get better. So the rider gets stuck, gets frustrated, and quits anyway.

Rule two

If you want to compete, you have to partly own a lesson horse.

Even for a little playday. Not full ownership. Just a real share.

That second rule did more for my business than anything else I've ever done. Showing costs the barn a lot. Now the family asking for it helps pay for it.

I lost about two thirds of my clients.

But look at what really happened

Before
After
Clients
50
18
Rides each, per week
1
2
Paid rides a week
50
36
Did everybody pay?
No
Yes
Clients−64%
Before
50
After
18
Paid rides a week−28%
Before
50
After
36

Client count is a bragging number. Paid rides is the number that buys hay.

I lost 64% of my clients. I only lost 28% of my rides.

Client count is a bragging number. Paid rides is the number that buys hay.

Then things I didn't plan for started happening

What changed
Why it mattered
I needed less help
Fewer schedules, fewer texts, fewer problems to sort out
Kids got good fast
Good riders don't need a full lesson every time. Some rides became supervised rides. Cheaper for me. Still paid.
We cut way down on horses
Every horse gone is feed, shoes, vet, insurance, a stall. This saved me the most.
Three kids bought horses
A kid at the barn twice a week gets attached. Owning starts to feel normal.

Then came the best part

Once those families owned horses, we made them a deal. Cheaper board, if we can use their horse in two lessons a week.

Who wins

Me

Lesson horses I don't buy, feed, or insure

The horse

Stays fit instead of standing in a stall five days a week

The parents

A smaller bill every month

One horse, doing two jobs, on three people's behalf.

It's also the best thing I have for keeping clients. A boarding barn down the road can't match that deal. They don't have a lesson program to trade with.

Setting it up right took me a long time. What a fair share costs. How big the discount should be. What has to be in writing. That part runs on the numbers from step one, and it's what I'm putting in the workbooks.

But the idea is free. Ask yourself: what do I already have that could be doing two jobs?

All of this runs on knowing your real cost per horse and per lesson hour. The calculator gets you that in an evening.

3

I got an outside opinion

The third thing was admitting I couldn't see my own barn clearly.

That's not a personal failing. You've walked past the same problem ten thousand times. It stopped looking like a problem years ago. It's just scenery now.

Somebody from outside spots it on day one. To them it isn't scenery. It's money.

Mine came from my small business professors in the MBA program. That was worth more than anything I learned in class.

Here's why. When you built something yourself, every line on the page has a story attached. That's the client who's been with you eight years. That's the horse you couldn't sell for what he's worth.

Those stories are real. They're also what stops you from seeing the truth.

They told me where to cut. Three things came out of it.

What I quit doing myself
Barn work
10–20Hours a week
→ a ranch manager
Show weekends
goneAll season
→ a coach
Horses standing
idleBetween events
→ a second job

None of it was work only I could do.

What I handed off
What I got back
Barn work → a ranch manager
10 to 20 hours a week. Cost barely more than the odd help I was already paying for.
Show weekends → a coach
My week back. And the show kids got somebody whose actual job is showing.
Idle rope horses → a second job
We taught them the barrel pattern and leased them out. Lease money covers their vet, shoes, insurance, and feed.

Two things I want to point out.

We had housing sitting empty. A building on my place earning nothing. Once you see the empty house and the manager as one decision, it stops being an expense. I'd looked at that house every day for years and never counted it.

And the rope horses meant one horse doing two jobs. My horse count stayed small, which is the thing that actually kills barns. Every extra horse is another mouth, another set of shoes, another stall.

One hard rule: no horse of ours is ridden more than five times a week. This only works if they stay sound and happy. Grind them to make the numbers work and you've traded a good horse for a good month.

What actually changed

None of these three were about working harder. I was already working as hard as I could. That was the problem.

The MBA didn't give me a secret. It gave me a better question.

I stopped asking “how do I do more of this?” I started asking: what is this really costing me, and what else could it do?

You don't need a degree to ask that. You need your numbers.

And you don't have to get them the way I did. On a kitchen table. For tens of hours. Out of nine different notebooks.

Start where I started — just faster.

The Horse Business Pricing Calculator is my own system, cleaned up for you. Put your costs in. It shows you what one horse and one lesson hour really cost, what you're keeping, and what you should be charging. Works in Excel, Numbers, or Google Sheets.

Get the Pricing Calculator →
Coming later this year

Four horse business workbooks — one each for boarding barns, lesson barns, training, and per-service work. That's where the rest of this lives.

Kate Evans, MBA, is a 6× National Champion and the founder of Highbrow Ranch and Life in Stride Riding Academy, where she has taught for eighteen years.

Back to blog